Cribs are not interchangeable
A swinging crib and a bedside crib have different designs and instructions. The mattress is part of that sleeping system. Before considering materials or covers, identify the model and its approved mattress specification.
What I would look at
I would want a clear description of the core and cover, sensible cleaning instructions and evidence about the finished product. “Luxury” is a description; it does not tell you how a mattress is built.
A thin mattress is not automatically unsuitable, and a thicker one is not automatically an improvement. Follow the crib manufacturer’s limits.
Buying second-hand equipment
Check that the crib is complete and that you can obtain the correct instructions. For a bedside crib, inspect the attachment system and follow the manufacturer’s setup requirements. Do not improvise a mattress or use extra padding to make an ill-fitting one work.
Further reading: The Lullaby Trust. Checked 17 November 2026.