best cot mattressA CLOSER LOOK AT QUALITY
← Back to the best cot mattress guide

Cot Mattress Materials: Foam, Fibre, Springs and Coir

Foam, fibre, springs or coir? Let’s get past the label and look at the construction.

02 / INSIDE THE MATTRESS

Which cot mattress
materials should you choose?

Foam, springs, fibre and natural fillings can be combined in very different ways. Ask what is actually inside, in what quantity, and how it is put together.

01

Not all foam is the same

“Nursery foam”, “luxury foam” and “support foam” are descriptions — meaningless marketing expressions on their own, not specifications. A meaningful answer gives you the foam’s density and firmness, with an explanation of how those figures are measured.

Let’s get into the nitty-gritty — I want to make you a foam expert!

First, which kind of foam are we talking about?

Let’s separate conventional mattress foam from memory foam. They’re different, and I wouldn’t choose a soft, body-moulding memory foam mattress for a baby. That sinking-in feeling might appeal to an adult, but a baby needs a firm, flat sleeping surface with waterproof protection.

When I talk about foam here, I mean conventional foam in a mattress specifically designed for babies. The complete mattress still needs to meet the requirements of its intended use. Read The Lullaby Trust’s mattress guidance.

Density: how much does the foam weigh?

Foam is a familiar material in baby mattresses, but how do you judge what you’re getting? Start with the specification. “Comfy-womfy” might raise a smile, but it doesn’t tell you much about what’s beneath the cover.

Density tells you how much material is packed into a given space. It’s measured in kilograms per cubic metre — kg/m³.

Imagine putting a block of foam one metre wide, one metre long and one metre high onto some scales. If it weighs 25 kilograms, its density is 25 kg/m³. If it weighs 30 kilograms, its density is 30 kg/m³. Same-sized block, different weight. Simple enough — although finding room for it in the kitchen might be another matter.

Does heavier mean better?

When comparing similar conventional foams, higher polymer density can be a useful indication of greater durability. But density and firmness are different things: heavier foam isn’t automatically firmer. Formulation, fillers and the complete construction matter too.

These are my buying preferences, rather than standard quality grades:

  • Under 20 kg/m³: I’d want convincing durability evidence before considering it.
  • 25–28 kg/m³: A range I would consider, alongside the firmness, construction and test results.
  • 30 kg/m³ and above: This is where my interest increases when looking for a durable conventional foam core.

Weight alone isn’t the only factor in assessing foam quality. We also need to look at how the foam compresses under pressure and how it recovers when that pressure is removed.

Firmness: how much force makes a dent?

There’s another useful foam measurement called ILD — indentation load deflection, also known as IFD, indentation force deflection. It sounds terribly technical, but it measures firmness under specified conditions.

Imagine pressing your hand into a piece of foam. Does it resist, or does your hand sink in easily? A laboratory test measures that resistance using controlled equipment and conditions.

One common test measures the force needed to compress the foam by 25% of its original thickness. A 10cm-thick sample would be pressed down to 7.5cm, not down to a quarter of its size.

The force needed to compress the foam is measured in newtons. Using the same test method, 130 newtons means the foam takes more force to compress than 120 newtons.

My preference is for a firmer grade around 130 newtons or above, alongside a suitable density and evidence of good recovery.

Put the two together: 35/135.

A foam with a density of 35 kg/m³ and an ILD firmness rating of 135 newtons can be described as 35/135 in this grading format.

The first number tells you the density. The second tells you the firmness — our “squash factor”.

When a manufacturer gives you those details and explains the test used, that gives you something meaningful to compare. To me, it shows they’re prepared to stand behind their specification.

Rather more useful than “comfy-wumfy nursery foam”, wouldn’t you say?

A little spring in the foam.

Some manufacturers take this a step further by shaping the foam into individual circular spring-like components, as you can see in the picture alongside. The spaces between them allow air to move through the core, and the construction is designed to give a springier feel than a solid block of foam. How warm the finished mattress feels also depends on its other layers and cover.

In my experience, making this construction work well calls for a higher-quality, more expensive foam. I prefer the feel of a well-made foam-spring core to a solid block — but the foam specification still matters.

OK, let’s now talk about metal pocket springs.

Mattress cutaway showing individual shaped foam springs between foam layers
Foam springs: shaped foam components inside a foam-based mattress. Image from The Cot Mattress Company.
02

Let’s talk about metal pocket springs.

The springs form the central core of the mattress. But your baby isn’t lying directly on them — the materials around them matter just as much.

The springs can be completely enclosed by either coir or foam — above, below and around the full perimeter of the spring unit.

Good springs still need good foam.

Take a 10cm-deep mattress with a 5cm spring unit. That leaves roughly 2.5cm above and below the springs if divided equally, before allowing for the cover and other layers.

That isn’t a great deal of foam, so its quality matters.

If the foam loses its shape, the mattress can develop a dip even while the springs underneath remain in good condition. A spring unit cannot rescue a poor-quality layer above it.

That’s why I ask about the foam’s density and firmness, rather than stopping at the words “pocket sprung”. If you’re buying for several years of use, look for evidence that the complete mattress keeps its shape and support.

I like the springier feel of a well-made pocket-sprung construction. The foam and springs work together, with the finished surface remaining firm and flat.

And don’t forget the edges.

Once your little rascal is holding onto the cot rails, bouncing up and down with a lovely smile, the mattress gets a proper workout. They’re delighted with themselves — and your mattress has just become the trampoline it never applied to be.

Because our smiling Jumping Jack puts extra pressure around the perimeter, I use a firmer supporting frame around the springs. The edges have a different job from the layers above and below — they need to hold their shape while your little athlete puts them through their paces.

03

Why I don’t recommend fibre.

I tried selling fibre mattresses because the price was attractive. I bought what I considered the best fibre available, but it didn’t perform as I expected. That experience is why I stopped recommending it.

For my money, I would choose a well-specified, good-quality foam mattress over a budget fibre mattress. Recovery and durability matter more to me than the saving on day one.

04

Let’s chat about coir — the coconut connection.

Coir is the tough fibre from a coconut’s outer husk. The hairy bit, if you like. An unlikely ingredient for a baby mattress? Perhaps, but it has a useful job to do.

Those fibres can be formed into a firm sheet, often bonded with natural latex to hold them together. The fibres are processed and formed into layers, then cut to the size needed for the mattress. We don’t need a tour of the whole factory to understand the basic idea.

A solid coir core can feel very firm — almost brick-like. The wool provides a cushioning layer over that core, while the finished sleeping surface still needs to remain firm and flat.

And the wool? We know who supplies that.

The sheep deserve a mention.

In this construction, wool takes the place of the foam layers we discussed earlier. It sits on the top and bottom of the coir core, beneath the mattress’s cover — not around the sides. The exact thickness of each layer depends on the design.

What interests me is how the materials work together: the coir core, the wool layers, the cover and the waterproof protection. Ask what each part contains and how the complete mattress is put together.

Two basic coir constructions to understand.

The first is straightforward: a solid coir core, with wool on the top and bottom.

The second has a spring unit inside a coir enclosure. There’s a layer of coir above and below the springs, plus a firm coir frame around the full perimeter. Wool then goes over the top and underneath the bottom — not around the edges.

In the sprung construction I’m describing, that perimeter frame is at least 6cm wide, so the springs stop short of the mattress edge. The firm coir border supports the edges when our smiling Jumping Jack starts giving them a workout.

So the difference is simple: a solid coir core, or springs enclosed in coir — both with wool on the top and bottom.

A material I rate for durability.

In my experience, most manufacturers making this type of mattress use good-quality coir, and I would expect a well-made coir mattress to provide at least five years of service with appropriate care.

I’ve even heard from customers whose mattresses are now being used for their third baby. That’s their reported experience, rather than a promise for every mattress — its condition and the manufacturer’s instructions still matter.

And that brings us to the phrase “new baby, new mattress”. We’ll come back to that later.

Coir, with a spring in its step.

That brick-like feeling got me thinking: could I keep the coir, but change the construction to introduce more give?

So I developed a different approach. Instead of metal springs inside the coir enclosure, I used individual springs made from coir and natural latex. The surrounding coir and wool remain part of the construction.

Picture a spring unit with 200 metal springs. Now imagine replacing them with individual coir-and-natural-latex springs, arranged closely together. That’s the idea behind my design: changing the springs themselves, rather than simply adding natural fillings around metal springs.

I developed this natural spring core for The Cot Mattress Company, which I own. You’ll find it in our mattress called The Excellence. Take a closer look at the natural spring design →

Natural materials still need practical care.

Wool isn’t a substitute for waterproof protection. Whatever is inside the mattress, keep spills away from the core and follow the cleaning instructions. The finished mattress needs a firm, flat sleeping surface, with suitable waterproof protection. Read The Lullaby Trust’s mattress guidance.

LET’S HAVE A LOOK INSIDE

Same job.
Very different insides.

A cover can hide quite a lot. These construction images from The Cot Mattress Company show why it pays to ask what is underneath. They illustrate individual products, not every mattress made from these materials.

Foam with foam springs
Foam with foam springsAn all-foam construction. These shaped foam components are different from metal springs.
Foam with pocket springs
Foam with pocket springsIndividual metal springs in fabric pockets, surrounded by foam. Ask about the foam grade as well as the springs.
Coir and lambswool
Coir and lambswoolA natural-material core example. Check the full specification: the cover and waterproof layer are separate parts.
Coir, metal springs and lambswool
Coir, metal springs and lambswoolA combination of materials. The word “natural” on its own cannot describe every component.
Coir and natural latex springs
Coir and natural latex springsA different kind of spring construction: this example uses coir and latex rather than metal.

Images supplied by The Cot Mattress Company and reused with permission. The writer has a commercial interest in the company. Construction examples are not comparative test results.

Natural materials, with a twist? Explore Natural Spring →

FOLLOW YOUR CURIOSITY

What would you like
to look at next?